Index Funds or Managed Funds? How MoneyPlan Invests, in Plain English
The short answer
For most long-term investors, low-cost index funds beat managed funds, because fees are certain and outperformance is not. MoneyPlan recommends index funds, held through a low-fee platform such as InvestNow, with Luis Silva setting the plan and you running it.
- Managed funds pay people to pick winners. They charge more, and most fail to beat their market over 10+ years.
- Index funds and ETFs simply own the whole market at very low cost. You keep more of the return.
- InvestNow has no account fee and a wide range of index funds, but its Foundation Series charges 0.50% on each buy and sell. That matters for small balances and regular top-ups, covered honestly below.
Funds in 60 seconds
A fund pools money from thousands of people and buys a basket of shares or bonds. The only real question is who chooses the basket.
- Managed (active) fund: a team picks the investments and tries to beat the market. You pay for their research and trading.
- Index fund: follows a list, such as the 500 largest US companies or the global share market. No guessing, no star manager, so costs stay tiny.
- ETF: an index fund you buy and sell on a stock exchange, like a share. Same idea, different wrapper.
If the market returns 6% before costs, an investor in the index gets close to 6%. An investor in a managed fund gets 6% minus a higher fee, plus or minus whatever the manager’s picks add.
Managed funds vs index funds
Index funds win on cost, predictability and simplicity. Managed funds only win if you can pick the manager in advance, which almost nobody can.
| Managed fund | Index fund / ETF | |
|---|---|---|
| Goal | Beat the market | Match the market |
| Typical yearly fee (NZ) | about 0.8% to 1.5% | about 0.05% to 0.30% |
| Who decides | A manager and analyst team | A published index list |
| Result vs market (long run) | Most lag after fees | Market return minus a tiny fee |
| Predictability | Low: depends on one team | High: you know what you own |
| Tax efficiency | Often more trading | Low trading, fewer surprises |
| Best for | Niche areas where skill may show | Core long-term growth |
What fees do to $100,000
On $100,000 held 25 years at a 6% market return before fees, a typical managed fund leaves you about $73,600 behind an index fund. Fees compound against you just as returns compound for you.
| Option | Yearly fee | Value after 25 years |
|---|---|---|
| Index fund (InvestNow Foundation Series) | 0.07% plus 0.50% in and 0.50% out | about $417,900 |
| Managed fund, lower fee | 0.76% | about $358,500 |
| Managed fund, typical fee | 0.93% | about $344,300 |
The index option here already includes the 0.50% transaction fees each way. This is an illustration, not a forecast: it assumes the managed fund earns exactly the market return before fees. If it beats the market by enough, it can come out ahead, but you cannot know that in advance.
What the evidence says
Over 10 to 20 years, the large majority of active share funds trail their benchmark index after fees. The long-running S&P SPIVA scorecards show this year after year, across the US, Australia and other markets.
- Survivorship: poor funds get closed or merged, so the surviving track records look better than the real experience.
- Persistence: last decade’s top performers rarely stay on top, so picking a winner from the past is a coin toss.
- Honest exceptions: results are less one-sided in some areas, such as parts of fixed income and small companies. Active can work there, but you pay for it with certainty.
The fair counterargument is that a smaller market like New Zealand leaves more room for skilled managers. Some have done well. The problem remains that you only know who after the fact.
Why MoneyPlan recommends index funds and self-investing
MoneyPlan is fee-only: Luis Silva is paid by you, not by fund companies, so there is no commission pushing you toward expensive products. That makes the recommendation about your outcome.
- Cost is the one thing you control. You cannot predict returns, but you can choose what you pay.
- Diversification is built in. One index fund holds hundreds or thousands of companies.
- You own it directly. Investing through your own platform account means your money is in your name, with no adviser fee charged on top of the funds.
- The plan matters more than the picks. Savings rate, asset mix and staying invested drive most of the result. That is the work MoneyPlan does with you.
Self-investing means you place the buys and top-ups yourself, following a plan agreed with your adviser. It takes minutes a few times a year. If you will panic-sell in a crash, say so early, because behaviour costs more than any fee.
Platforms compared: fees and coverage
InvestNow is the best fit for a core, long-term index portfolio; the others win in specific cases. Fees as published in October 2025; check each provider before acting.
| Platform | Account fee | Dealing fees | Coverage | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| InvestNow | None | None on most funds; 0.50% buy and sell on Foundation Series (Vanguard-powered PIE funds) | Many NZ fund managers, index funds, KiwiSaver | Core index portfolio, many fund choices |
| Sharesies | Plan-based, from free | Transaction fees up to 1.9%, capped; about 0.5% FX | NZ, Australian and US shares, ETFs and funds | Beginners, small amounts, mixing shares and funds |
| Kernel | Low, fund-based | Low-fee index funds | Index funds and KiwiSaver, narrower menu | Simple, cheap index investing |
| Hatch, Stake, Tiger | Flat or per-trade | Per-trade fees on US shares | US shares and ETFs | Buying specific US stocks and ETFs |
| ASB Securities, Craigs | Brokerage per trade | Brokerage plus FX | NZX, ASX and global shares | Larger direct share portfolios |
Coverage differs more than price: Sharesies and the brokers reach individual shares, while InvestNow and Kernel are built for funds. Do not buy individual shares to avoid a fund fee unless you accept the extra risk.
Tax: why PIE funds simplify life
For most New Zealanders, a PIE fund is simpler and often cheaper to tax than holding overseas shares directly.
- PIE funds: tax is paid inside the fund at your PIR, capped at 28%, even if your marginal rate is up to 39%. The fund handles the overseas-share rules, so you file nothing extra.
- Direct overseas shares: under the foreign investment fund (FIF) rules, once your overseas holdings cost more than NZ$50,000 you are taxed on a deemed 5% return (the FDR method) at your marginal rate, whether or not you sold anything.
- Australian ASX index funds: some approved index funds are exempt from FIF, a useful exception.
Confirm your PIR and your situation with a tax adviser. This section is general information only.
Where this approach does not fit
InvestNow’s Foundation Series charges 0.50% every time you buy or sell, and InvestNow itself says it may not suit everyone. Be honest about whether you are in these groups:
- Small balances or frequent small top-ups: 0.50% on each deposit adds up. Lower-dealing-fee alternatives, such as Kernel, Smartshares funds through Sharesies, or InvestNow funds without transaction fees, may cost less.
- Short horizons (under about 5 years): the entry and exit fees have little time to be repaid by low ongoing fees.
- Lower tax rates: if your marginal rate is below 28%, a PIE’s 28% cap may not help you.
- Unstable behaviour: if you will sell in a downturn, the cheapest fund will not save you.
For a lump sum held ten years or more, the 0.50% each way is a small price. For $200 a fortnight, test the alternatives first. Index funds are the right core for most people. Which platform carries them depends on your numbers.
How this works with MoneyPlan
You do not have to do it alone. Luis Silva gives expert, prescriptive advice and you stay in control of your money.
- Plan: goals, timeframe, risk and your real numbers.
- Prescription: the exact mix of index funds, and the platform that costs least for your situation.
- Set up: open the account in your own name; Luis guides each step.
- Run it: automatic top-ups, one review a year, no tinkering.
Book a conversation to get started.
Sources and disclaimer
- InvestNow: fees and Foundation Series
- Sharesies pricing
- Kernel Wealth
- S&P SPIVA scorecards
- Inland Revenue: PIE and FIF rules
Fee illustration is MoneyPlan’s own calculation at a 6% pre-fee return over 25 years. Fees and rules change; confirm with each provider before acting.
This paper is general information, not personalised financial advice. Luis Silva, MoneyPlan, FSP1009370.
Want a plan built around your situation?
Start with a free 30-minute discovery session. No obligation, no preparation needed. Fixed, published fees if you go ahead.
Get new articles by email
One short email when a new article is published. No spam, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
This article is general information only and is not personalised financial advice. For advice on your own situation, book a free discovery session.
← Back to Blog