Blog

Why MoneyPlan Has No Minimum. And What That Says About How Most Advisers Work.

A client asked me recently why I did not have a minimum. They had contacted other advisers before reaching out to MoneyPlan and had been told, in one form or another, that their situation was not quite at the right stage yet. Too little saved. Not enough in the portfolio. Come back when the number is bigger. They wanted to know why the same rule did not apply here. It is a fair question, and the honest answer reveals quite a lot about how the financial advice industry is structured.

Why most advisers have minimums

When an adviser sets a minimum, say $200,000 in investable assets, or $500,000, the number is not arbitrary. It is a revenue calculation. Most advisory businesses that set minimums are paid through one of two models: a percentage of the assets they manage on your behalf, or commissions earned when you buy financial products through them. In both cases, the size of your portfolio determines how much the adviser earns from you.

If an adviser charges 1% per year on assets under management, a client with $100,000 generates $1,000 annually. A client with $1,000,000 generates $10,000. Same work, potentially. Very different income. The minimum exists to protect the business model, not to protect the client.

Payment modelWhy minimums appearWho benefits from the threshold
% of assets managedSmall portfolios generate very little income at 0.5% to 1.5% per yearThe adviser. A $200k minimum filters out low-revenue clients.
Commission on productsClients with less to invest buy smaller policies and funds, generating less commissionThe adviser. Product volume drives income, not client need.
Flat fee for work doneFee is set by the complexity and scope of the work, not the size of the portfolioThe client. A person earning well but not yet wealthy pays the same rate as anyone else at the same stage of complexity.

The fee-only model removes the reason for a minimum entirely. The fee reflects the work involved, not the size of the number on a balance sheet. A person who earns well, has a mortgage, is building KiwiSaver, and has no income protection in place has a genuinely complex financial situation. The fact that they have not yet accumulated a large portfolio does not make their situation simpler or less worth addressing carefully.

The people who most need a proper financial plan are often the ones being turned away for not having one already.

The gap the minimum creates

Here is what actually happens when advisers set high minimums. Busy professionals in their thirties and forties, earning good incomes and carrying real financial complexity, get quietly filtered out. They have a mortgage with years left to run. They have KiwiSaver contributions going somewhere but no real understanding of whether it is the right fund. They have no income protection, or they have a policy they signed years ago that may no longer fit their situation. They have goals: retire early, buy an investment property, reduce debt systematically. But they have not yet accumulated the kind of portfolio that makes them “worth” advising in a commission or percentage-of-assets model.

Who gets turned away: a high earner, early to mid career. Strong income, mortgage, growing KiwiSaver, no insurance review in years. No large investment portfolio yet. Told to come back later. This is often when the most important decisions get made badly.

Who MoneyPlan works with: anyone with real financial complexity. The measure is whether the work is meaningful and whether a proper plan will make a material difference to someone’s outcome. That question has nothing to do with the current portfolio size.

The irony is that the people being turned away are often at the stage where the decisions matter most. The habits built now, the debt structured correctly now, the insurance gaps closed now, compound in both directions. Getting it right early has more impact than getting it right once a large portfolio already exists.

What does determine whether we work together

No minimum does not mean no criteria. There is a different question being asked: not “how much do you have?” but “is there meaningful work to do, and are you ready to engage with it seriously?”

  • Your financial situation has real complexity: income, debt, insurance, KiwiSaver, goals, and cashflow that need to be looked at together rather than in isolation.
  • You are willing to share a full picture of your finances, not just the parts that feel comfortable. A partial picture produces a partial plan.
  • You are looking for a plan built around your situation, not a product recommendation dressed up as advice.
  • You understand that a fee-only engagement means paying for the work directly, and you see that as the structure most likely to produce advice that is genuinely in your interest.
  • You are ready to act on what a plan recommends, not just receive it and file it away.

These are the things that make an engagement worthwhile. None of them are related to how much is currently sitting in a portfolio.

The question behind the question

When someone asks why there is no minimum here, they are often really asking something else: am I important enough to work with? The answer is straightforward. The measure of whether you are worth working with is whether the work will make a real difference to your financial life. For most people who reach out, it will.

Minimums exist because of how advisers get paid, not because of what clients need. When payment comes directly from the client as a fee for work done, the threshold disappears. What remains is a simpler question: is there meaningful work to do here, and can it be done well?

That is the only filter that matters. If you have been told you are not quite there yet by someone else, it is worth considering whether that answer was about your situation or about their business model.

Want a plan built around your situation?

Start with a free 30-minute discovery session. No obligation, no preparation needed. Fixed, published fees if you go ahead.

Book a free session

This article is general information only and is not personalised financial advice. For advice on your own situation, book a free discovery session.

← Back to Blog